| Sezon |
Półfinał (1. mecz) |
Półfinał (rewanż) |
Finał |
| 2004/2005 |
Sheffield Wednesday 1–0 Brentford
Hartlepool United 2–0 Tranmere Rovers |
Brentford 1–2 Sheffield Wednesday
Tranmere Rovers 2–0 Hartlepool United
(6:5 dla Hartlepool w rzutach karnych) |
Sheffield Wednesday 4–2 Hartlepool United po dogr. |
| 2005/2006 |
Barnsley 0–1 Huddersfield Town
Swansea City 1–1 Brentford |
Huddersfield Town 1–3 Barnsley
Brentford 0–2 Swansea City |
Barnsley 2–2 Swansea City
(4:3 dla Barnsley w rzutach karnych) |
| 2006/2007 |
Yeovil Town 0–2 Nottingham Forest
Oldham Athletic 1–2 Blackpool |
Nottingham Forest 2–5 Yeovil Town po dogr.
Blackpool 3–1 Oldham Athletic |
Yeovil Town 0–2 Blackpool |
| 2007/2008 |
Southend United 0–0 Doncaster Rovers
Leeds United 1–2 Carlisle United |
Doncaster Rovers 5–1 Southend United
Carlisle United 0–2 Leeds United |
Leeds United 0–1 Doncaster Rovers |
| 2008/2009 |
Scunthorpe United 1–1 MK Dons
Millwall 1–0 Leeds United |
MK Dons 0–0 Scunthorpe United
(7:6 dla Scunthorpe w rzutach karnych)
Leeds United 1–1 Millwall |
Scunthorpe United 3–2 Millwall |
| 2009/2010 |
Swindon Town 2–1 Charlton Athletic
Huddersfield Town 0–0 Millwall |
Charlton Athletic 2–1 Swindon Town
(5:4 dla Swindon w rzutach karnych)
Millwall 2–0 Huddersfield |
Millwall 1–0 Swindon Town |
| 2010/2011 |
Bournemouth 1–1 Huddersfield Town
Milton Keynes Dons 3–2 Peterborough United |
Huddersfield Town 3–3 Bournemouth
(4:2 dla Huddersfield w rzutach karnych)
Peterborough United 2–0 Milton Keynes Dons |
Huddersfield Town 0–3 Peterborough United |
| 2011/2012 |
Sheffield United 0–0 Stevenage
Huddersfield Town 2–0 Milton Keynes Dons |
Sheffield United 1–0 Stevenage
Huddersfield Town 1–2 Milton Keynes Dons |
Huddersfield Town 0–0 Sheffield United
(8:7 dla Huddersfield w rzutach karnych) |
| 2012/2013 |
Sheffield United 1–0 Yeovil Town
Swindon Town 1–1 Brentford |
Yeovil Town 2–0 Sheffield United
Brentford 3–3 Swindon Town
(5:4 dla Brentford w rzutach karnych) |
Brentford 1–2 Yeovil Town |
| 2013/2014 |
Peterborough United 1–1 Leyton Orient
Preston North End 1–1 Rotherham United |
Leyton Orient 2–1 Peterborough United
Rotherham United 3–1 Preston North End |
Leyton Orient 2–2 Rotherham United
(4:3 dla Rotherham United w rzutach karnych) |
| 2014/2015 |
Chesterfield 0–1 Preston North End
Sheffield United 1–2 Swindon Town |
Preston North End 3–0 Chesterfield
Swindon Town 5–5 Sheffield United |
Preston North End 4–0 Swindon Town |
| 2015/2016 |
Barnsley 3–0 Walsall
Bradford City 1–3 Millwall |
Walsall 1–3 Barnsley
Millwall 1–1 Bradford City |
Barnsley 3–1 Millwall |
| 2016/2017 |
Millwall 0–0 Scunthorpe United
Bradford City 1–0 Fleetwood Town |
Scunthorpe United 2–3 Millwall
Fleetwood Town 0–0 Bradford City |
Bradford City 0–1 Millwall |
| 2017/2018 |
Charlton Athletic –-1 Shrewsbury Town
Scunthorpe United 2–2 Rotherham United |
Shrewsbury Town 1–0 Charlton Athletic
Rotherham United 2–0 Scunthorpe United |
Rotherham United 1–1 Shrewsbury Town
(2:1 dla Rotherham United w dogrywce) |
| 2018/2019 |
Sunderland 1–0 Portsmouth
Doncaster Rovers 1–2 Charlton Athletic |
Portsmouth 0–0 Sunderland
Charlton Athletic 2–3 Doncaster Rovers
(4:3 dla Charlton Athletic w karnych) |
Charlton Athletic 2–1 Sunderland |
| 2019/2020 |
Portsmouth 1–1 Oxford United
Fleetwood Town 1–4 Wycombe Wanderers |
Oxford United 1–1 Portsmouth
(5:4 dla Oxford United w karnych)
Wycombe Wanderers 2–2 Fleetwood Town |
Oxford United 1–2 Wycombe Wanderers |
| 2020/2021 |
Oxford United 0–3 Blackpool
Lincoln City 2–0 Sunderland |
Blackpool 3–3 Oxford United
Sunderland 2–1 Lincoln City |
Blackpool 2–1 Lincoln City |
| 2021/2022 |
Wycombe Wanderers 2–0 Milton Keynes Dons
Sunderland 1–0 Sheffield Wednesday |
Milton Keynes Dons 1–0 Wycombe Wanderers
Sheffield Wednesday 1–1 Sunderland |
Sunderland 2–0 Wycombe Wanderers |
| 2022/2023 |
Peterborough United 4–0 Sheffield Wednesday
Bolton Wanderers 1–1 Barnsley |
Sheffield Wednesday 5–1 Peterborough United
(5:3 dla Sheffield Wednesday w karnych)
Barnsley 1–0 Bolton Wanderers |
Barnsley 0–0 Sheffield Wednesday
(0:1 dla Sheffield Wednesday w dogrywce) |
| 2023/2024 |
Barnsley 1–3 Bolton Wanderers
Oxford United 1–0 Peterborough United |
Bolton Wanderers 2–3 Barnsley
Peterborough United 1–1 Oxford United |
Bolton Wanderers 0–2 Oxford United |
