| Rok |
Miasto |
Organizator |
Zwycięzca |
Outstanding Wrestler |
|---|
| 1974 | Wilkes-Barre | Wilkes University | Wilkes University | Jim Fallis (Lakers) |
| 1975 | University Heights | John Carroll University | John Carroll University | Nabil Guketlov (Red Hawks) |
| 1976 | Cedar Rapids | Coe College | Montclair State University | Vince Tundo (Red Hawks) |
| 1977 | Binghamton | Binghamton University | The College at Brockport | Andy Zook (Marauders) |
| 1978 | Wheaton | Wheaton College | University at Buffalo | Ken Mallory (Red Hawks) |
| 1979 | Arcata | Humboldt State University | The College of New Jersey | Jeff Freedman (Eagles) |
| 1980 | New London | US Coast Guard Academy | The College at Brockport | Tom Jacoutot (Bulls) |
| 1981 | University Heights | John Carroll University | The College of New Jersey | Jeff Bouslog (Norse) |
| 1982 | Cortland | State University of New York | The College at Brockport | Frank Famiano (Golden Eagles) |
| 1983 | Wheaton | Wheaton College | The College at Brockport | Frank Famiano (Golden Eagles) |
| 1984 | Binghamton | Binghamton University | The College of New Jersey | Bob Glaberman (Lions) |
| 1985 | Rock Island | Augustana College | The College of New Jersey | Tim Jacoutot (Lions) |
| 1986 | Trenton | The College of New Jersey | Montclair State University | Nick Milonas (Red Hawks) |
| 1987 | Buffalo | University at Buffalo | The College of New Jersey | John Monaco (Red Hawks) |
| 1988 | Wheaton | Wheaton College | St. Lawrence University | Tim Jacoutot (Lions) |
| 1989 | University Heights | John Carroll University | Ithaca College | Pete Gonzalez (Red Hawks) |
| 1990 | Ithaca | Ithaca College | Ithaca College | Rob Llorca (Warhawks) |
| 1991 | Rock Island | Augustana College | Augsburg University | Rob Llorca (Warhawks) |
| 1992 | Trenton | The College of New Jersey | The College at Brockport | Peter Wang (Maroons)
Raphael Wilson (Augie) |
| 1993 | New London | US Coast Guard Academy | Augsburg University | Gary Kroells (Auggies) |
| 1994 | Stevens Point | University of Wisconsin | Ithaca College | Raphael Wilson (Augie) |
| 1995 | Rock Island | Augustana College | Augsburg University | Tom Layte (Augie) |
| 1996 | Cortland | State University of New York | Wartburg College | Ron Vosburg (Golden Eagles) |
| 1997 | Ada | Ohio Northern University | Augsburg University | Aaron Fitt (Warriors) |
| 1998 | Dubuque | Loras College | Augsburg University | Matt Hamill (Tigers) |
| 1999 | Trenton | The College of New Jersey | Wartburg College | Matt Hamill (Tigers) |
| 2000 | Ada | Ohio Northern University | Augsburg University | Josh Cagle (Augie) |
| 2001 | Waverly | Wartburg College | Augsburg University | Nick Ackerman (The Storm) |
| 2002 | Wilkes-Barre | Wilkes University | Augsburg University | Jimmy Wallace (Quakers) |
| 2003 | Ada | Ohio Northern University | Wartburg College | Rami Ratel (Red Hawks) |
| 2004 | Dubuque | Loras College | Wartburg College | Joe Moon (Augie) |
| 2005 | Northfield | St. Olaf College | Augsburg University | Ryan Allen (Eagles) |
| 2006 | Trenton | The College of New Jersey | Wartburg College | Duane Bastress (Spartans) |
| 2007 | Dubuque | Loras College | Augsburg University | Matt Pyle (Norse) |
| 2008 | Cedar Rapids | Coe College & Cornell College | Wartburg College | Josh Chelf (Eagles) |
| 2009 | Cedar Rapids | Coe College & Cornell College | Wartburg College | Michael Wilcox (Aggies) |
| 2010 | Cedar Rapids | Coe College & Cornell College | Augsburg University | Vincent Renaut (Mariners) |
| 2011 | La Crosse | University of Wisconsin | Wartburg College | Myanganbayar Batsukh (Johnnies) |
| 2012 | La Crosse | University of Wisconsin | Wartburg College | Kodie Silvestri (Knights) |
| 2013 | Cedar Rapids | Cornell College | Wartburg College | Greg Sanders (Falcons) |
| 2014 | Cedar Rapids | Cornell College | Wartburg College | Nazar Kulczycki (Titans) |
| 2015 | Hershey | Elizabethtown College | Augsburg University | Mike Fuenffinger (Augie) |
| 2016 | Cedar Rapids | Coe College & Cornell College | Wartburg College | Riley Lefever (Little Giants) |
| 2017 | La Crosse | University of Wisconsin | Wartburg College | Riley Lefever (Little Giants) |
| 2018 | Cleveland | ---- | Wartburg College | Lucas Jeske (Augie) |
| 2019 | Roanoke | Ferrum College | Augsburg University | Jay Albis (Wildcats) |
| 2022 | Cedar Rapids | ---- | Wartburg College | Bradan Birt (Big Blue) |
| 2023 | Roanoke | Ferrum College | Augsburg University | Jaritt Shinhoster (Warhawks) |
| 2024 | La Crosse | University of Wisconsin | Augsburg University | Chase Randall (Bears) |
| 2025 | Providence | Johnson & Wales University | Wartburg College
Johnson & Wales University | Jared Stricker (Blugolds) |
